Articles

What does a 90% chance of success mean?

Our calculator's “90% chance of success” means that when your plan was run against 5,000 different sequences of market history, the money lasted to your planning age in 90 of every 100 of them.

More often than not, people read that as having a 10% chance of going broke. That is not true. Those are the simulated retirements where the money ran out before your planning age.

A failure can come early or late

A simulated retirement counts as a failure if the money runs out at any point before your planning age. The default planning age is 95 in our calculator, and you can change it.

The plan that runs out at 71 and the one that runs out at 94 can be seen as the same failure rate. However, two plans can both show 90% and fail in very different ways.

In a failing simulation, the household keeps spending against their plan every month until they deplete their money. It is unlikely, though, that they would go on a spending spree.

MangoDime does model one adjustment, the spending guardrail. After a year in which your investments lose money, it halves your discretionary spending for the next year. If the money lasts, that simulated retirement still counts as a success, even though some years got less than the full budget. The failures are the simulations where even the cut wasn't enough. MangoDime will help you track the account balances and adjust the available spending capacity by showing new post-tax monthly income.

The number changes when your assumptions change

Change your planning age from 95 to 90 and the percentage goes up, though your finances are the same. The number answers one question: will this spending last to this age under these returns? Your 90% and somebody else's 90% can be totally different if the target ages are different.

Is a higher number always better?

No. A plan that lasts in every simulation will usually leave a large unspent balance. You will have a lot of money left over at the end. But will that make you happy? If your dream is to retire and enjoy life traveling and relaxing, yet you're still afraid to spend because it feels uncomfortable, you may be wasting your life for the feeling of security. We wouldn't chase 99%. The healthier goal is a balance between security and enjoying the retirement you saved for.

What counts as a good number?

MangoDime sorts the percentage into four bands. We chose them ourselves.

  • 90% and above: on track. Above about 95%, it's worth asking whether you're under-spending.
  • 75% to 90%: mostly on track. This holds up if some of your spending is discretionary and could flex in a bad decade.
  • 50% to 75%: at risk. The plan only works when markets are good and when your spending, retirement age, savings rate and Social Security start all go as planned.
  • Below 50%: needs attention. Closing the gap takes either more savings or significantly lower spending. Small changes are unlikely to be enough.

We put the line at 90% to match your sustainable monthly income, which is the highest monthly spending that lasted in 90 of 100 simulated retirements.

What the percentage doesn't show

How much of your spending could flex. A household with $2,000 a month of discretionary spending can cut back in a bad market. But if you have only listed out the essentials, you have little to dial back.

How much will you get monthly? Social Security and a pension cover part of your spending no matter how markets perform. The more they cover, the less market swings affect your retirement income.

The order of the years. Two retirements with the same average return can end very differently if the bad years come first, because money withdrawn from a falling balance doesn't recover. Your risky years, on the dashboard, shows which years in your plan are most exposed.

What this doesn't model

The simulation replays past market history against your plan, so it can't know about anything that hasn't happened yet. The returns come from every year from 1928 through 2025, drawn in runs of consecutive years, so 1929, 1973 and 2008 are all in the history our 5,000 simulations draw from.

It also doesn't model how you'd react. Apart from the spending guardrail, every simulated household keeps to the plan even as the money runs out. That tends to make the results conservative.

Where to look in your own plan

The percentage is on your dashboard, with its band beside it. Your risky years, also on the dashboard, shows which years a bad market would hurt most. The Stress test on the Compare page puts a real crash, such as 2008, in your first year of retirement. So try that out.

Last updated November 9, 2026 · MangoDime